New York Joins 43-State Push to Block CFTC Sports-Contracts Swap Rule

The attorneys general say federal derivatives oversight would weaken state gambling controls and consumer safeguards.
Key points
  • A coalition of 43 state attorneys general and the District of Columbia asked the CFTC to withdraw its proposed sports-event-contracts rule.
  • The states argue that sports bets are not financial derivatives and that the agency lacks authority to classify them as swaps.
  • The group warned that prediction-market operators could evade state licensing, age restrictions and problem-gambling protections.
  • It also opposed an interim CFTC rule that distinguishes casino-style, house-backed games from other forms of gambling.
  • The CFTC must consider the comments before determining the proposal’s future.
New York Joins 43-State Push to Block CFTC Sports-Contracts Swap Rule

New York Attorney General Letitia James joined 42 other state attorneys general and the District of Columbia in urging the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw a proposed rule that would expressly treat sports-related event contracts as swaps.

The bipartisan coalition argued that the agency lacks statutory authority to recast sports bets as derivatives. It said such contracts are not swaps, futures or other financial instruments because they do not serve hedging, price-discovery or similar financial purposes.

The group was co-led by the attorneys general of Ohio, Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee and Utah. Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson said the CFTC could not create powers that Congress had not granted, ignore federal court decisions or override state consumer protections.

The attorneys general said the proposal would expand federal control into an area traditionally overseen by states, giving the CFTC what they described as a virtual veto over state gambling policy. Their comments argued that the rule conflicted with the Commodity Exchange Act and raised major-questions, federalism and constitutional nondelegation concerns.

Consumer protection was central to the states’ objections. The coalition warned that prediction-market platforms could bypass state licensing requirements, age limits and problem-gambling protections. It also said conventional sportsbooks could reorganize as prediction markets to avoid state gambling laws and the safeguards attached to them.

The CFTC’s proposal, published Oct. 9, would define swaps to include event contracts tied to sports, politics, culture and weather. Chairman Michael S. Selig has said the agency considers event contracts to be commodity derivatives within its exclusive jurisdiction under the Commodity Exchange Act.

The states also objected to a separate interim final rule, already in effect, that excludes casino-style gambling products, including sportsbook wagers and casino games, from the swap definition. The CFTC said that rule codified its longstanding view that casino-style gambling products are not derivatives and was intended to clarify the boundary between federal derivatives oversight and state and tribal gambling jurisdiction.

Maryland Attorney General Anthony G. Brown’s office said the coalition viewed the interim rule as drawing an improper distinction between house-backed casino games and peer-to-peer betting. The attorneys general argued that gambling has never been confined to house-backed games, and that the distinction conflicts with the agency’s prior guidance and recent court decisions.

The intervention builds on a July coalition letter, in which Ohio and eight other named states, including New York, urged the CFTC to preserve state authority over sports-related prediction markets. That letter said 38 states and the District of Columbia permit some form of sports betting, while state regulation covers licensing, advertising, consumer protections, problem-gambling limits and tax rates.

The coalition also challenged the proposed rule’s adoption while only one CFTC commissioner was serving, arguing that the agency lacked a quorum. The CFTC must consider the submitted comments before it decides whether to finalize, modify or withdraw the proposal.

21+ in OH. Please play responsibly. For help, call the Ohio Problem Gambling Helpline at 1-800-589-9966 or 1-800-GAMBLER.

Latest news