Kalshi Warns New York Order Could Shut Its Exchange Nationwide

The company says a proposed restraining order could force liquidation of all open event-contract positions, while New York calls its sports markets unlicensed gambling.
Key points
  • A federal judge sent New York’s enforcement action against Kalshi back to Manhattan state court on Nov. 20.
  • New York has refiled its request for a temporary restraining order blocking Kalshi from operating within or from the state.
  • Kalshi and a CFTC lawyer said the proposed order could require liquidation of open positions and halt the exchange nationwide.
  • The case turns on whether Kalshi’s sports-event contracts are federally regulated derivatives or unlawful wagers under New York law.
Kalshi Warns New York Order Could Shut Its Exchange Nationwide

Kalshi has warned that a temporary restraining order sought by New York could require the prediction-market operator to liquidate every open position and cease operating its exchange nationwide, rather than simply block New York customers.

The warning came in a letter filed late Nov. 19 by Kalshi’s lawyers, who sought an immediate hearing before any emergency order was issued. On Nov. 20, U.S. District Judge Vernon S. Broderick returned Attorney General Letitia James’s enforcement case to New York Supreme Court in Manhattan, allowing the state to pursue the requested restraint there.

James refiled the request on Friday. The proposed order would bar event-contract business conducted within or from New York, covering markets on sports, elections, culture and other events. Kalshi is headquartered in New York City, and its attorney Sean Murphy argued that the relief would reach beyond the court’s jurisdiction and disrupt markets across the country.

Murphy said the order would likely force the liquidation of all open positions. CFTC attorney Andrew Weisberg separately told a federal judge that the order New York sought would completely shut down Kalshi’s operations nationwide. Kalshi argued that moving its exchange would require regulatory filings, infrastructure and clearing changes, personnel moves and compliance reviews, while doing nothing by itself to end New York’s claims over past conduct.

New York alleges that Kalshi runs an illegal, unlicensed gambling business by allowing customers to stake money on sporting outcomes without a state sports-wagering licence. The state contends that labelling the transactions financial contracts does not exempt them from its gambling laws, which it says protect children and help address gambling addiction.

Kalshi maintains that its contracts are federally regulated derivatives and that it operates a CFTC-certified designated contract market. The earlier federal ruling described event contracts as derivatives with payouts tied to specified events, but denied Kalshi’s request for a preliminary injunction on July 7, finding that the Commodity Exchange Act did not pre-empt New York gambling laws as applied to the company’s sports contracts.

As we reported Nov. 3, the Second Circuit subsequently denied Kalshi protection from New York enforcement while its appeal proceeds. The legal question remains whether sports-event contracts are federally regulated financial products or wagers governed by state gambling law.

New York’s petition traces the dispute to an Oct. 24, 2025 cease-and-desist directive from the Gaming Commission, followed three days later by Kalshi’s federal challenge. James filed the current enforcement suit in July, alleging eight causes of action under the New York Constitution, state gambling laws and the federal Wire Act. The state seeks permanent injunctions, an accounting, restitution, disgorgement, damages and civil penalties; court filings reference about $36 billion in requested monetary relief, subject to accounting and not an award or established debt.

The CFTC sought emergency federal intervention to stop New York from restricting Kalshi, but a federal judge rejected that request on Nov. 20. James’s office has also brought a separate Manhattan case seeking records on Kalshi’s marketing and advertising, including influencer arrangements.

21+ in OH. Please play responsibly. For help, call the Ohio Problem Gambling Helpline at 1-800-589-9966 or 1-800-GAMBLER.

Latest news